Orlando's Italian restaurant scene ranges from Michelin-recommended trattorias in charming historic neighborhoods to world-class fine dining establishments serving imported truffles, vintage Barolo, and scratch-made pasta. Here is your definitive guide to the best Italian restaurants in Orlando.
Top 5 Italian Restaurants in the Greater Orlando Area
1. Christini's Ristorante Italiano (7600 Dr Phillips Blvd)
For over 35 years, owner Chris Christini has welcomed world leaders, dignitaries, and celebrities to his elegant dining room on Restaurant Row. Acclaimed for authentic Northern Italian classics, tableside accordion melodies, and flawless European service.
2. Prato (Park Ave, Winter Park)
Consistently ranked among Central Florida's top culinary destinations, Prato blends Italian tradition with modern American seasonal ingredients. Highlights include mustard spaetzle with braised pork, house-extruded pasta, and blistered wood-fired pizzas.
3. Mia's Italian Kitchen (8717 International Dr)
A bustling, vibrant restaurant on I-Drive using recipes passed down from the chef's Sicilian grandmother. The house-made gnocchi, giant stuffed meatballs, and Roman-style pan pizzas are crowd favorites.
4. Il Mulino New York Trattoria (Walt Disney World Swan Resort)
Bringing Greenwich Village elegance to Lake Buena Vista, Il Mulino is renowned for handmade ravioli, veal parmigiana, and complimentary antipasti baskets.
5. BiCE Ristorante (Loews Portofino Bay at Universal Orlando)
Overlooking Portofino Bay's picturesque harbor piazza, BiCE delivers classic Milanese sophistication, fresh carpaccio, and seafood risotto.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most famous upscale Italian restaurant in Orlando?
Christini's Ristorante Italiano on Restaurant Row in Dr. Phillips is world-renowned for fine dining, celebrity guests, white-glove service, and house-made fettuccine Alfredo.
Where can I get bottomless pasta and pizza on International Drive?
Mia's Italian Kitchen on I-Drive is famous for its scratch-made pastas, giant meatballs, Roman-style square pizzas, and optional bottomless dining experiences.